Why Do Some Criminal Offenses Result in Fines — and Others Result in a Jail Sentence? 8 Things to Know

Image source: Unsplash

Have you ever wondered why the punishment for some criminal offenses results in fines whereas others result in imprisonment? If so, here are eight things you will want to know.

1. Misdemeanors Are Less Serious Crimes Than Felonies

To comprehend why some punishments for criminal offenses result in fines while others result in jail time, you must first understand the foundations of criminal law. Within the U.S. legal framework, crime is separated into minor (or misdemeanor) and major (or felony) offenses.

Felonies are serious crimes that carry severe punishments, including imprisonment, whereas misdemeanors encompass less severe crimes, like petty theft and public intoxication, and the punishment can range from fines to jail time of under one year.

Murder, aggravated assault, and large-scale fraud are just some types of felonies that can incur long prison sentences. But there are different levels of felonies. 

For instance, the punishment for 3rd degree felony crimes like the possession of Class A drugs could result in both fines and multiple years in prison whereas a serial killer could face life imprisonment – or even death, depending on the state. 

2. The Punishment Is Often Based on the Nature of the Crime 

In the U.S. justice system, punishment often correlates with the severity of a criminal act. Non-violent infractions like traffic violations usually result in fines, as their impact on society is generally minor.

On the other hand, violent crimes such as murder or assault tend to lead to imprisonment due to their detrimental effects on societal safety.

3. Public Safety Is Taken into Account During Sentencing

Sometimes the punishments given for criminal offenses are considered public safety. If an offender’s actions pose a persistent risk to society, because of repeated DUI offenses, for example, incarceration might be chosen over financial penalties.

Ensuring public safety is always high on the list for judicial authorities when considering penalties. 

4. An Offender’s Criminal History Can Matter 

An offender’s prior history with crime can come into play during sentencing decisions too. A first-time offender may be given lighter punishment, such as a fine for a misdemeanor offense. But if crime becomes habitual for them, their penalties will naturally escalate.

This system serves a dual purpose: deterrence and the prevention of criminal lifestyle normalization. 

5. Mitigating or Aggravating Factors Matter Too 

In determining the penalty for a crime, courts may consider any mitigating or aggravating factors. For instance, provocation may reduce the severity of punishment in some assault cases.

Conversely, if a person was involved in an act of cruelty or deceit during their offense, it could lead to more severe sanctions.

6. Plea Bargaining Can Affect Sentencing

In cases of plea bargaining, sentences are usually reduced. When an accused person pleads guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for a reduction in sentence, they frequently avoid jail and instead pay fines. Sometimes, they go to jail but for a shorter period.

7. Victim Statements Can Also Affect Sentencing

An often-overlooked aspect that can influence sentencing is victim impact statements. These provide a platform for victims or their families to express how the crime has affected them personally. Judges take these statements into account when deciding if a case warrants imprisonment or a fine. 

8. Constitutional Protections Play a Role 

Lastly, constitutional protections play a significant role in determining punishments for all crimes, both big and small. The Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prohibits imposing excessive fines or cruel and unusual punishments.

If courts determine that punitive fines are disproportionate to an offense, they could opt for other forms of punishment that respect constitutional limits.